High Court Rules in Favour of Claimant in Forgery Case

Dobson-Grey acted as a crucial Expert Witness in a High Court case that concluded in July 2024, resulting in a significant victory for the Claimant. The case involved allegations of forgery, undue influence, and fraudulent property transfers. Our role focused on providing highly specialised and defensible property valuations at critical points in time.

Dobson-Grey’s Expert Witness Contribution

Keri Dobson, our appointed Expert Witness, delivered comprehensive property valuation services that proved instrumental to the successful outcome. Keri’s role encompassed:

  • Comprehensive “Pre-Works” Valuations: Executing meticulous and robust valuations of the properties, establishing a credible basis for financial remedies.
  • Detailed Expert Reporting: Producing clear, concise, and defensible written reports outlining valuation methodologies and findings.
  • Impartial Oral Testimony: Providing expert oral evidence in court, clearly articulating complex legal principles and responding to scrutiny with professionalism and impartiality.

The Judge’s Affirmation of Expert Evidence

he Judge’s judgment systematically addressed the Claimant’s core arguments, confirming:

  • Undue Influence: The court found that the Defendants had indeed exerted undue influence over the Claimant.
  • Resulting Trust: It was established that the Claimant intended to retain beneficial ownership of the properties, thus establishing a resulting trust.
  • Unlawful Means Conspiracy: The court upheld the Claimant’s claim of unlawful means conspiracy, specifically concerning the Defendants’ forgery of her signature on a Property Sale Agreement (PSA) and its subsequent misuse.

The presiding Judge explicitly praised Keri Dobson’s expertise and impartially, accepting her valuations as the basis for calculating substantial financial remedies awarded to the Claimant.

“there is no doubt about Ms. Dobson’s expertise …and body of knowledge underpinning it; and I would add she was plainly impartial and trying to assist the Court, especially in her oral evidence.”

This case exemplifies a successful collaboration leading to a just outcome and highlights the court’s commitment to addressing fraudulent conduct.

Latest Projects

VIEW ALL PROJECTS

  • Comprehensive condition survey of a two-storey public house

    Comprehensive condition survey of a two-storey public house A client required a comprehensive condition survey of a two-storey public house as part of their lease agreement finalisation. The property had been unoccupied for approximately two years, making a detailed assessment of its current state critical. Dobson-Grey, conducted a crucial condition survey. Our team carried out…
    Read More

  • Defect Report – Window Installation

    Defect Report – Window Installation Dobson-Grey Ltd. was instructed to provide an Expert Witness Defect Report. Our lead surveyor, an experienced Chartered Surveyor and Registered Valuer, led the technical investigation. Their extensive background in RICS HomeBuyer Condition Surveys, valuations, snagging, and project management of window installations in heritage properties provided the foundation for a comprehensive…
    Read More

  • Shakespeare Marina, Stratford-upon-Avon

    Shakespeare Marina, Stratford-upon-Avon Dobson-Grey Ltd were instructed to undertake a retrospective and prospective strategy and planning review of a leisure-based development site with a complex planning history, located in a sensitive riverside location on the edge of Stratford-upon-Avon.  It was necessary for the previously approved development to evolve to meet changing economic circumstances and to…
    Read More